Head-to-head comparison
Middle-earth™: Shadow of Mordor™ vs Red Dead Redemption: who wins?
The early direct score is Middle-earth™: Shadow of Mordor™ 0-1 Red Dead Redemption. Compare both games, then make your pick.
Make your pick
Which game do you like more?
0 local picks
Your pick stays on this device. Sign in only when you want to save it.
Direct matchups1
- Overall Elo
- 1,495 vs 1,552
- Ranking signals
- 9 vs 9
- Release years
- 2014 vs 2010
- Shared genres
- Action
Head-to-Head Comparison Matrix
Attribute
Middle-earth™: Shadow of Mordor™
Red Dead Redemption
Release Year
2014
2010
Public Elo
1,495
1,552
Direct Score
0 wins (0%)
1 wins (100%)
Genres
Action, RPG, Adventure
Action, Shooter
Platforms
PlayStation
PlayStation, PC, Xbox, Nintendo
Which should you play?
Red Dead Redemption is the stronger pick from the available ranking signal.
Play Middle-earth™: Shadow of Mordor™ if
- Choose Middle-earth™: Shadow of Mordor™ if you want Action / RPG first.
- Choose Middle-earth™: Shadow of Mordor™ if its Elo score of 1,495 fits your bar.
Play Red Dead Redemption if
- Choose Red Dead Redemption if you want Action / Shooter first.
- Choose Red Dead Redemption if its Elo score of 1,552 fits your bar.
Skip this matchup if
- Skip both if neither genre matches what you want to play today.
- Rank your own library if public results do not match your taste.
How this comparison works
The direct result counts head-to-head player choices between these two games. The Elo scores use every eligible public pick involving each game, so they add broader ranking context when the direct matchup is still close.
One pick is an early signal, not a final verdict. Rank your own library to see which game wins for your taste.